Don’t Make Them Guess: Why Advance Care Planning Begins with a Conversation

Published on November 18, 2026

Written by Kathy Benich, MBA, PMP, End-of-Life Educator and Founder of Marigold Path

Advance care planning (ACP) is often associated with advance directives and documenting treatment preferences. These documents represent only part of the process.

As Thanksgiving approaches, families across the country will gather around tables filled with familiar foods, traditions, and conversations. We’ll catch up on family news, share memories, debate whose recipe is best, and perhaps revisit stories we’ve heard dozens of times.

Our families know our favorite foods, our habits, and the stories that have shaped our lives.

But how well do they know what matters most to us?

Would they know what we consider an acceptable quality of life? What medical interventions we might be willing to endure? What circumstances might cause us to reconsider treatment? And would the person we trust to make healthcare decisions on our behalf feel prepared to do so?

These are not necessarily questions to introduce between the turkey and pumpkin pie. But the holiday season offers an opportunity to begin conversations that too often wait until a medical crisis makes them unavoidable.

Holding hands.

Advance Care Planning Is More Than a Document

At its heart, advance care planning is about understanding and communicating what matters most to an individual so that future healthcare decisions can reflect that person’s values, goals, and preferences.

A 2025 review, Advance Care Planning: What, When, and How?, identifies two central objectives of ACP: establishing goals of care consistent with an individual’s wishes and identifying an appropriate surrogate decision-maker (Toledo-Franco L, et al, 2025).

An advance directive cannot anticipate every clinical circumstance. Someone might express a preference to avoid mechanical ventilation, for example, but that preference may depend on whether ventilation offers a reasonable likelihood of recovery or would merely prolong the dying process.

The document provides guidance. The conversation provides context.

A systematic review of 132 randomized trials found more consistent evidence that ACP improves communication, reduces decisional conflict, and increases agreement between patients and caregivers about treatment preferences than that it changes longer-term patient outcomes or healthcare utilization (Malhotra C, et al, 2022).

Advance care planning helps prepare people to navigate decisions that cannot be predicted.

When the Hypothetical Becomes Personal

My background in project management has always made me inclined to plan ahead. Shortly after my husband, John, and I married, we began discussing our values, preferences, and expectations for medical care.

Over our 26 years of marriage, we revisited those conversations periodically. Medicine advanced, laws and legal precedents evolved, and our perspectives matured. We updated our documents and discussed what quality of life meant to each of us.

Those conversations felt practical and relatively straightforward.

Then John was diagnosed with stage IV colon cancer.

Suddenly, conversations that had once been hypothetical became intensely personal. We were no longer talking about circumstances that might occur someday. We were talking about John, his illness, and an uncertain prognosis.

And the conversations became much harder.

For approximately 18 months, chemotherapy and immunotherapy managed his cancer effectively. Eventually, however, the treatments became less effective, and additional options carried increasing burdens and potential complications.

During one particularly difficult hospitalization, we revisited a conversation we had begun years earlier. John had always believed that quality of life mattered more to him than simply extending life.

As the holidays approached, he decided he wanted to spend New Year’s Eve in New Orleans, a city where he had lived in his youth and a place we had visited together many times. Knowing what we had discussed, I wondered whether this might be our last trip together.

A couple of months later, another treatment stopped working. Sitting in his oncologist’s office, John said he did not want to continue cancer-directed treatment.

Those were extraordinarily difficult words to hear.

But because we had discussed his values long before that moment, I understood his decision. I knew what mattered to him, and I could focus on how best to support him.

We had previously discussed his preference to die at home and his desire to prioritize comfort in pain management. Those conversations helped us navigate the transition to hospice care without requiring him to revisit every difficult question.

Our earlier planning did not eliminate the grief or make the experience easy. But it spared me a different kind of anguish: wondering whether I was honoring his wishes.

In a time of grief and confusion, that difference matters.

It matters to know that you are doing right by your person.

Understanding Quality-of-Life Thresholds

One of the most meaningful aspects of advance care planning is exploring what I think of as quality-of-life thresholds: the conditions, abilities, relationships, and experiences that shape whether someone considers a particular treatment or outcome acceptable.

Preferences about resuscitation, artificial nutrition, or mechanical ventilation often depend on what those treatments might make possible.

One person may prioritize independence; another may find meaning in communicating with loved ones or participating in activities despite substantial physical limitations.

In my work as an end-of-life educator, I encourage people to reflect on which abilities matter most to them and how they would want to be cared for as they approach the end of life.

I once worked with a woman whose mobility was extremely limited. Someone observing her physical condition might have assumed that her quality of life was poor. Yet when music began playing, her eyes lit up. She joined in, singing along and visibly enjoying the experience.

Music brought her joy.

That experience reinforced an important principle: We cannot define another person’s quality of life through our own expectations.

A condition that one person considers intolerable may be entirely acceptable, even joyful, to another. Assumptions about disability, dependence, or physical limitations can obscure the experiences that continue to give someone’s life meaning.

Quality-of-life thresholds are personal reflections, not universal standards for determining whether life is worth living.

They can also change.

Someone who previously prioritized comfort might accept additional treatment burdens because they hope to attend a daughter’s wedding or see a grandson graduate. Another person may initially pursue aggressive treatment but reconsider as the likelihood of benefit decreases.

Neither necessarily represents inconsistency. Goals evolve as circumstances, prognosis, and personal priorities change.

This is why advance care planning should be an ongoing conversation rather than a one-time exercise.

Choosing Someone Who Can Make the Decisions

Identifying a healthcare decision-maker is one of the most consequential components of advance care planning.

But do we consider what we are asking that person to do?

Choosing someone we love and trust is important. But trust alone does not necessarily mean someone is prepared to make complex medical decisions under emotionally difficult circumstances.

A surrogate may need to interpret unfamiliar medical information, weigh uncertain outcomes, communicate with clinicians, and navigate family disagreements. Perhaps most challenging, that person may need to support a decision that differs from what they would choose for themselves.

In my community education programs, I have observed an interesting pattern among some parents of young adult children. While they may designate one another as their primary healthcare decision -maker, they sometimes choose a sibling or close family friend as their alternate rather than one of their adult children.

When I ask why, many express a desire to protect their children from the emotional burden of making these decisions. I encounter that concern less frequently among parents whose children are older.

These observations are not findings from a formal study. They do raise a question: Are we choosing decision makers based on family relationships or their readiness for the responsibility?

Research supports the importance of looking beyond the designation itself.

In a study exploring patient and surrogate perspectives, McMahan and colleagues identified several elements of preparation, including selecting surrogates thoughtfully, ensuring they understand their responsibilities, clarifying how much discretion they should have, and communicating preferences to other family member (McMahan, RD, et al, 2013).

In another study, approximately 73% of the 198 spokespersons interviewed reported feeling very prepared for surrogate decision-making. This was self-reported preparedness, not an objective assessment of readiness. Participants’ accounts highlighted comfort with uncertainty, personal characteristics, and relationships (Thiede E, et al, 2021).

These findings suggest that naming someone in a document is not the same as preparing that person to act.

The conversation should include more than asking, “Will you be my healthcare decision-maker?”

We should also ask whether that person feels capable of making difficult decisions, understands your values, and would be willing to advocate for those values even when doing so is emotionally painful.

It is equally important to give someone permission to decline.

Not everyone is comfortable with this responsibility, and acknowledging that limitation is not a reflection of how much they love us.

Choosing a healthcare decision-maker is not an honorary designation. It is asking someone to take on a significant responsibility. We owe it to them, and to ourselves, to ensure they understand what that responsibility involves.

When the Goals of Care Change

Advance care planning also provides a foundation for conversations when medical treatment is no longer accomplishing what a person hopes it will.

For patients, families, and clinicians, these conversations can be difficult. Continuing treatment may represent hope, determination, or a commitment to doing everything possible. Discussions about changing treatment goals can feel like surrender.

Hospice care is sometimes caught in this misunderstanding.

I believe hospice should be understood as part of the continuum of good medical care, not as evidence that medicine has failed.

Hospice is not simply what happens when medicine has nothing left to offer. It is what medicine can offer when the goals of care shift toward comfort and quality of life.

For eligible patients who choose hospice, the emphasis moves toward symptom management, emotional and spiritual support, and helping individuals and families navigate and make the most of the time remaining.

That shift does not necessarily mean abandoning hope. It may mean redefining what one hopes for.

Hope for a cure may become hope for meaningful time together. Hope for another treatment may become hope for relief from pain, an opportunity to return home, or participation in an important family occasion.

Palliative care can support patients throughout serious illness, alongside disease-directed treatment. Hospice provides a more specific approach when prognosis, eligibility, and personal goals make that care appropriate.

For John, discontinuing cancer-directed treatment did not mean he had stopped caring about life. It meant that the burdens of continued treatment no longer aligned with how he wanted to spend the time he had remaining.

Our earlier conversations helped me understand that distinction.

Before Everyone Leaves the Table

Thanksgiving need not become a formal advance care planning session.

Gathering with people we love offers an opportunity to recognize what we still need to understand about one another.

Perhaps the conversation begins with a question about what makes life meaningful. Perhaps someone shares an experience caring for an aging parent or a friend facing serious illness. Perhaps the holiday simply provides an opportunity to arrange a quieter conversation in the days ahead.

The important thing is to begin.

Ask yourself what matters most to you. Consider what abilities, relationships, and experiences contribute to your quality of life. Think about whom you would trust to speak for you, and whether that person is willing and prepared to assume the responsibility.

Then have the conversation. Document your wishes in accordance with applicable state requirements, make sure your decision-maker and healthcare team can access the information, and revisit it as your circumstances change.

Advance care planning cannot eliminate uncertainty. Medical circumstances change, prognoses are imperfect, and preferences may evolve. Even well-prepared families can face difficult decisions.

But preparation can reduce a different kind of uncertainty: not knowing what the person would want.

We can give the people who love us something invaluable: an understanding of what matters most.

When the time comes, they may still have difficult decisions to make.

We can help ensure they do not have to make those decisions by guessing.

This Thanksgiving, take the opportunity to share what matters most with loved ones so that future healthcare decisions can reflect your values, goals, and preferences.

About the Author

Kathy Benich is an end-of-life educator, cancer research advocate, and founder of Marigold Path. Drawing on her experience as a caregiver for her late husband and nearly 30 years in healthcare advisory and systems leadership, she helps individuals and families explore what matters most and prepare for conversations about serious illness and end-of-life care. Through community education and patient advocacy, she encourages thoughtful planning that honors individual values and supports the people who may someday speak on our behalf.

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kathybenich 

Verified by MonsterInsights